Ah, what could have been. I love the premise (superhero who couldn’t care less and is universally hated), and the way it’s presented in the first ten, maybe twenty minutes. What comes afterwards, not so much.
So, fine, PR guy Ray feels sorry for the man (perhaps, too, because he arguably just saved Ray’s life), is unsuccessful himself, and comes up with the pitch of actually making John Hancock well-liked. And his wife isn’t fond of the idea, what with all the collateral damage that is John’s trademark with anything he does. Still amusing.
And amusing, too, to see the alcoholic superhero actually join an anonymous group. For countless meetings, he passes, never speaking up. But this subplot is never resolved: even when finally urged to by the others, he only mutters a few words, not actually introducing himself.
It goes downhill from there. Ray urges Hancock to turn himself in. When, as predicted by Ray, the police actually ask for his help, and he does his job politely and fabulously (and is applauded for it and suddenly a beloved community member), the movie is pretty much over. Well, it should be. Sorry, another 40 minutes to go! Gee, how do we fill them…
Oh yeah! Let’s go all Dogma style, reveal that Jay’s wife is also Hancock’s wife, and that the two are in fact angels. Then, have the two senselessly fight each other and finally explain that, sorry, they can’t be close, lest they lose their powers in favor of mutual affection.
Yeah, that would make sense. Cut!
For a script stuck in development hell for a decade, pathetically little time was apparently put into improving it. The film doesn’t suffer from bad acting or from unoriginality, as is often the case with superhero flicks. It suffers from what’s-going-on incoherency, and from leaving you to wonder just what point it was trying to make.
Self-loathing people just need to disappear for a while as to become recognized as necessary and good? Alcoholism is something you just shed like a piece of skin? Women can be superheroes, too, but they’re too afraid to admit it, and become cranky liars when found out? Who knows.